DAMA finally released their new result after several years of operating the so called LIBRA detector containing 250-kg NaI crystals. And they claim to reconfirm the discovery of dark matter particles in the galactic halo. However, their new result hardly convinces the direct dark matter detection community of their claim. Just some quotes from experts in the field from Nature report, Guardian, and physicsworld.
Tim Sumner (from ZEPLIN experiment): “They’re seeing a signal, there’s no doubt about that”
Gilles Gerbier (from EDELWEISS experiment): “For me, it’s not proof that they have seen dark matter”
Bernard Sadoulet (from CDMS experiment): “it’s certainly not the dark matter we were looking for”
Henrique Araujo (ZEPLIN-III experiment): “No-one disputes that they observe an annual modulation, but the community needs to be persuaded that dark matter has anything to do with it.”
Richard Gaitskell (from CDMS and LUX experiments): “If I could have one thing for Christmas it would be to see clear calibration data showing the necessary stability.”
DAMA has posted two papers on arXiv, one about their experimental apparatus, another on their results. And they have the usual way to defend their results.
Rita Bernabei (DAMA spokesperson): “No other experiment whose result can be directly compared in model independent way is available so far”
I happened to be at LNGS to listen to Bernabei’s talk about their new results here a few days ago. And I would say the annual modulation signal must be something, but it’s definitely not the WIMP that we are looking for.



